A131431 → D+1 → D
nonnegative coefficientsonly rational roots
Proved for all n all roots real, in (−∞, 0]coefficients of one signHadamard kernel
Recurrence
\(\left(20 - 72\,n + 91\,n^{2} - 48\,n^{3} + 9\,n^{4}\right)\,P_{n}(x) = \left(-2\,n x^{2} - n^{2} x^{2} + 12\,n^{3} x^{2} - 9\,n^{4} x^{2}\right)\,P_{n-2}(x) + \left(20\,n x + 38\,n^{2} x - 60\,n^{3} x + 18\,n^{4} x\right)\,P_{n-1}(x)\)
\(P_{0}(x) = 0\)
\(P_{1}(x) = 4\)
\(P_{2}(x) = 14 + 14\,x\)
Rows ?
| n | x0 | x1 | x2 | x3 | x4 | x5 | x6 | Pn(1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | |||||||
| 1 | 4 | 4 | ||||||
| 2 | 14 | 14 | 28 | |||||
| 3 | 0 | 60 | 30 | 90 | ||||
| 4 | 0 | 0 | 156 | 52 | 208 | |||
| 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 320 | 80 | 400 | ||
| 6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 570 | 114 | 684 | |
| 7 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 924 | 154 | 1078 |
Compute more
?
Other recurrences
Derivative · proved equal for all n (proof step)
\(\left(-4 + 2\,x + 12\,n - 5\,n x - 11\,n^{2} + 3\,n^{2} x + 3\,n^{3}\right)\,P_{n}(x) = \left(-n x + n x^{2} - 2\,n^{2} x + 3\,n^{2} x^{2} + 3\,n^{3} x\right)\,P_{n-1}(x)\)
\(P_{0}(x) = 0\)
\(P_{1}(x) = 4\)
Technical details
- Node id
n-e1f285b6913430e1· revision 0 · JSON- Definition source
derived:one_plus_derivativederived:derivative(equal bye-86702e9cf90939cd)- Fingerprint
f6-2327141074f67bdf
Observed on the stored rows ?
- Degrees: -1, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 (affine: slope 1, intercept -1)
- Palindromic rows: no
- γ-positive (gamma_positive): no
- Nonnegative coefficients (
nonn): yes - Only rational roots (
rr_by_factors: every nonzero row is a product of linear factors over ℚ): yes
Matches ?
No OEIS matches.
Submission text ?
Atlas rows n = 0, …, ascending powers of x
%e ExampleTriangle begins: 0: 0; 1: 4; 2: 14, 14; 3: 0, 60, 30; 4: 0, 0, 156, 52; 5: 0, 0, 0, 320, 80; 6: 0, 0, 0, 0, 570, 114; 7: 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 924, 154; 8: 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1400, 200; 9: 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2016, 252;
%F FormulaThe row polynomials satisfy (9*n^4-48*n^3+91*n^2-72*n+20)*P(n,x) = -(9*n^4-12*n^3+n^2+2*n)*x^2*P(n-2,x) + (18*n^4-60*n^3+38*n^2+20*n)*x*P(n-1,x) for n >= 3, with P(0,x) = 0, P(1,x) = 4, P(2,x) = 14 + 14*x.
%t MathematicaP[0, x_] := 0;
P[1, x_] := 4;
P[2, x_] := 14 + 14*x;
P[n_, x_] := P[n, x] = Expand[Together[(-(9*n^4 - 12*n^3 + n^2 + 2*n)*x^2*P[n - 2, x] + (18*n^4 - 60*n^3 + 38*n^2 + 20*n)*x*P[n - 1, x])/(9*n^4 - 48*n^3 + 91*n^2 - 72*n + 20)]];
Table[CoefficientList[P[n, x], x], {n, 0, 9}] // Flatten%o PARI/GPP(N) = {my(v = vector(N + 1)); v[1] = 0; v[2] = 4; v[3] = 14 + 14*x; for(n = 3, N, my(i = n + 1); v[i] = (-(9*n^4 - 12*n^3 + n^2 + 2*n)*x^2*v[i - 2] + (18*n^4 - 60*n^3 + 38*n^2 + 20*n)*x*v[i - 1])/(9*n^4 - 48*n^3 + 91*n^2 - 72*n + 20)); v};
row(n, p) = {my(c = Vecrev(p)); c};
T(N) = {my(v = P(N)); concat(vector(#v, i, row(i - 1, v[i])))};
T(9)polytool c48629374597
Properties
- Real-rooted? Every row P_n, n ≥ 0, is zero or real-rooted with all roots in (−∞, 0]
- Coefficients of one sign? Every nonzero row, n ≥ 0: the coefficients of P_n have one sign
- Hadamard kernel (Malo)? Rows P_n, n ≥ 0, are Hadamard kernels (preserve real-rootedness)
Proof chains ? JSON
-
Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators [SP14] polytool ? step ›
-
from
one_plus_derivative of 3n + 1 preceded by n zeros.?
-
Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators [SP14] polytool ? step ›
-
from
3n + 1 preceded by n zeros.?
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences [SP14; Bra15, Thm 7.1 of arXiv:1410.6601] polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
Ray basis map theorem [MW08, Thm 2] polytool RealRooted rayBasisMap_maps_realRootedIn_iff ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
Geometric basis map (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
-
Gamma criterion RealRooted IsGammaExpansion.isRealRooted_and_hasRootsNonpos_iff ? step ›
-
from
Even-numbered rows of Pascal's triangle.?
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
Even-numbered rows of Pascal's triangle.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
-
Geometric basis map (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
Row-hypergeometric rows (multiplier sequences) [SP14; Bra15, Thm 7.1 of arXiv:1410.6601] polytool RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_eval_of_roots_nonpos RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_inv_ascPochhammer RealRooted RealRooted.IsPFMultiplierSequence.mul ? step › direct check
-
from
Even-numbered rows of Pascal's triangle.?
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Row-hypergeometric rows (multiplier sequences) (above)
-
from
Even-numbered rows of Pascal's triangle.?
-
Geometric basis map (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
-
Geometric basis map (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
-
Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences [ASW52; Edr53; AW24] polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
-
Gamma criterion RealRooted IsGammaExpansion.isRealRooted_and_hasRootsNonpos_iff ? step ›
-
from
binomial?
-
Row-hypergeometric rows (multiplier sequences) [SP14; Bra15, Thm 7.1 of arXiv:1410.6601] polytool RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_eval_of_roots_nonpos RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_inv_ascPochhammer RealRooted RealRooted.IsPFMultiplierSequence.mul ? step › direct check
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
binomial?
- ↑ Liu–Wang theorem (above)
- ↑ Row-hypergeometric rows (multiplier sequences) (above)
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
Riordan array (1-x,x/(1-x)).?
-
Row-hypergeometric rows (multiplier sequences) [SP14; Bra15, Thm 7.1 of arXiv:1410.6601] polytool RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_eval_of_roots_nonpos RealRooted RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_inv_ascPochhammer RealRooted RealRooted.IsPFMultiplierSequence.mul ? step › direct check
-
from
Riordan array (1-x,x/(1-x)).?
-
Gamma criterion RealRooted IsGammaExpansion.isRealRooted_and_hasRootsNonpos_iff ? step ›
-
from
binomial?
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
-
from
binomial?
-
Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators [SP14] polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
-
Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences [SP14; Bra15, Thm 7.1 of arXiv:1410.6601] polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
-
Geometric basis map (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
-
Affine-current basis map theorem polytool RealRooted orderTwoConstants_nonneg_iff ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
no recorded property covers this requirement
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
Affine-current basis map theorem polytool RealRooted orderTwoConstants_nonneg_iff ? step ›
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
no recorded property covers this requirement
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
- ↑ Ray basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Parent-row provers of polytool (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Veronese sections of Pólya frequency sequences (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Gamma criterion (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on differential operators (above)
- ↑ Laguerre’s theorem on multiplier sequences (above)
- ↑ Geometric basis map (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Iterated real-rootedness preservers (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
- ↑ Affine-current basis map theorem (above)
-
-
from
a(n) = 1 if n is a triangular number, otherwise 0.?
-
Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) polytool ? step ›
- ↑ Affine, reversal and Möbius substitutions (elementary) (above)
-
from
3n + 1 preceded by n zeros.?
-
-
from
one_plus_derivative of 3n + 1 preceded by n zeros.?
Related ?
Same fingerprint ?
- image under θ+1 → θ+1 → D+1
- A136572 → D+1
- A132440 → θ+1 → D+1
- A136572 → D → D+1
- A023531 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A021012 → D+1
- image under θ+1 → D+1
- A132440 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729, shifted → (θ+1)² → D+1
- Hadamard-factor parent of A127773 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A030528, shifted → θ+1 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729, shifted → θ+1 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A030528, shifted → (θ+1)² → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729, shifted → D+1
- A127773 → θ+1 → D+1
- A130123 → D+1
- A127648 → D → D+1
- A130123 → θ+1 → D+1
- A127773 → D+1
- A136572 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- image under θ+1 → θ+1 → D+1 → reverse
- image under θ+1 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- A131431 → θ+1 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729 → D → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A026729, shifted → D → D+1
- A127773 → D → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A021012 → θ+1 → D+1
- A131436 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A030528, shifted → D → D+1
- A131431 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- A131431 → D+1
- basis-map coefficients of A030528, shifted → D+1
- A127648 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- A130123 → D → D+1
- A130123 → (θ+1)² → D+1
- A136572 → θ+1 → D+1
- A131431 → D+1 → reverse
- image under θ+1 → θ+1 → D+1 → D
References
- [ASW52] Michael Aissen, I. J. Schoenberg and A. M. Whitney. On the generating functions of totally positive sequences I. Journal d’Analyse Mathématique, 2(1):93–103, 1952. doi:10.1007/BF02786970
- [AW24] Christos A. Athanasiadis and David G. Wagner. Veronese sections and interlacing matrices of polynomials and formal power series. arXiv:2404.12989. arXiv
- [Bra06] Petter Brändén. On linear transformations preserving the Pólya frequency property. Transactions of the American Mathematical Society, 358(8):3697–3716, February 2006. doi:10.1090/s0002-9947-06-03856-6
- [Bra15] Petter Brändén. Unimodality, log-concavity, real-rootedness and beyond. Handbook of enumerative combinatorics, :437–483, March 2015. doi:10.1201/b18255-10
- [Edr53] Albert Edrei. Proof of a Conjecture of Schoenberg on the Generating Function of a Totally Positive Sequence. Canadian Journal of Mathematics, 5:86–94, 1953. doi:10.4153/CJM-1953-010-3
- [LW07] Lily L. Liu and Yi Wang. A unified approach to polynomial sequences with only real zeros. Advances in Applied Mathematics, 38(4):542–560, May 2007. doi:10.1016/j.aam.2006.02.003
- [MW08] Shi-Mei Ma and Yi Wang. q-Eulerian polynomials and polynomials with only real zeros. The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, 15(1):Research Paper 17, January 2008. doi:10.37236/741
- [SP14] J Schur and G Polya. Über zwei Arten von Faktorenfolgen in der Theorie der algebraischen Gleichungen. J. Reine Angew. Math., 1914.