{"certification":{"candidate":{"gauge":{"kind":"none"},"index_shift":0,"operator":{"coefficients":[{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["2"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]}],"shape":"euler_polynomial"},"parent":{"first_index":0,"initial_polynomials":[["1"]],"recurrence":{"denominator":{"coeffs":[["0"],["4"],["1"]]},"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["4","2"],["5","5"],["1","3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"offset":1,"sign":"none"},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","2","-2"],["0","2","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"offset":1,"sign":"none"}]},"schema":"polytool.recurrence.v1"},"parent_name":"basis-map coefficients of Triangular array of generalized Narayana numbers: T(n, k) = 2*binomial(n + 1, k + 1)*binomial(n + 1, k - 1)/(n + 1). shifted by x ->  x + 1"},"identifying_rows":1,"identity":{"certificate":{"certificate":{"dividend_relation":{"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["-10","-60","-170","-360"],["-7","-118","-507","-1016"],["-1","-76","-581","-1188"],["0","-20","-327","-731"],["0","-2","-97","-247"],["0","0","-15","-43"],["0","0","-1","-3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","-46","-292","-1038","-424"],["0","-29","-554","-2761","-1600"],["0","-3","-332","-2887","-2316"],["0","0","-76","-1485","-1673"],["0","0","-6","-395","-637"],["0","0","0","-53","-121"],["0","0","0","-3","-9"]]},"deriv_order":1,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","-30","-200","-830","460"],["0","0","-17","-368","-2057","794"],["0","0","-1","-206","-2011","372"],["0","0","0","-40","-957","-81"],["0","0","0","-2","-227","-117"],["0","0","0","0","-25","-33"],["0","0","0","0","-1","-3"]]},"deriv_order":2,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","-4","-28","-132","164"],["0","0","0","-2","-50","-310","362"],["0","0","0","0","-26","-286","312"],["0","0","0","0","-4","-126","130"],["0","0","0","0","0","-26","26"],["0","0","0","0","0","-2","2"]]},"deriv_order":3,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["5","10","45"],["6","42","174"],["1","48","263"],["0","18","196"],["0","2","75"],["0","0","14"],["0","0","1"]]},"deriv_order":0,"shift":1},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","15","30","135"],["0","18","126","522"],["0","3","144","789"],["0","0","54","588"],["0","0","6","225"],["0","0","0","42"],["0","0","0","3"]]},"deriv_order":1,"shift":1},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","5","10","45"],["0","0","6","42","174"],["0","0","1","48","263"],["0","0","0","18","196"],["0","0","0","2","75"],["0","0","0","0","14"],["0","0","0","0","1"]]},"deriv_order":2,"shift":1}]},"exceptional_bases":[],"gauge":{"kind":"none"},"identifying_indices":[0],"index_shift":0,"input":{"first_index":0,"initial_polynomials":[["1"]],"recurrence":{"denominator":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0"],["4","-8","0"],["1","6","0"],["0","10","16"],["0","2","20"],["0","0","8"],["0","0","1"]]},"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["4","0","0","8"],["5","18","7","42"],["1","28","47","92"],["0","12","69","113"],["0","2","37","77"],["0","0","9","25"],["0","0","1","3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"offset":1,"sign":"none"},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","2","0","6","-8"],["0","2","10","22","-34"],["0","0","14","44","-58"],["0","0","4","42","-46"],["0","0","0","16","-16"],["0","0","0","2","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"offset":1,"sign":"none"}]},"schema":"polytool.recurrence.v1"},"input_valid_from_base":0,"multiplier":["5","6","1"],"operator":{"coefficients":[{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["2"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]}],"shape":"euler_polynomial"},"parent":{"first_index":0,"initial_polynomials":[["1"]],"recurrence":{"denominator":{"coeffs":[["0"],["4"],["1"]]},"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["4","2"],["5","5"],["1","3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"offset":1,"sign":"none"},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","2","-2"],["0","2","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"offset":1,"sign":"none"}]},"schema":"polytool.recurrence.v1"},"parent_leader_shift":1,"parent_valid_from_base":0,"quotients":[{"differentiations":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","5","0","30","-80","45"],["0","0","6","30","96","-306","174"],["0","0","1","46","168","-478","263"],["0","0","0","18","160","-374","196"],["0","0","0","2","71","-148","75"],["0","0","0","0","14","-28","14"],["0","0","0","0","1","-2","1"]]},"deriv_order":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","15","0","90","-240","135"],["0","0","0","18","90","288","-918","522"],["0","0","0","3","138","504","-1434","789"],["0","0","0","0","54","480","-1122","588"],["0","0","0","0","6","213","-444","225"],["0","0","0","0","0","42","-84","42"],["0","0","0","0","0","3","-6","3"]]},"deriv_order":1},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","0","5","0","30","-80","45"],["0","0","0","0","6","30","96","-306","174"],["0","0","0","0","1","46","168","-478","263"],["0","0","0","0","0","18","160","-374","196"],["0","0","0","0","0","2","71","-148","75"],["0","0","0","0","0","0","14","-28","14"],["0","0","0","0","0","0","1","-2","1"]]},"deriv_order":2}],"shift":0}],"row_annihilation":{"annihilator":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0"],["2"],["1"]]},"deriv_order":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["-3","-1"],["0","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","-1","1"]]},"deriv_order":2}],"kind":"single","quotient":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","0","310","230","-1390","850"],["0","0","0","0","677","1381","-4793","2735"],["0","0","0","0","503","2477","-6463","3483"],["0","0","0","0","151","1942","-4337","2244"],["0","0","0","0","15","740","-1525","770"],["0","0","0","0","0","133","-266","133"],["0","0","0","0","0","9","-18","9"]]},"deriv_order":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","0","0","120","400","-1160","640"],["0","0","0","0","0","264","1480","-3752","2008"],["0","0","0","0","0","198","2100","-4794","2496"],["0","0","0","0","0","60","1454","-3088","1574"],["0","0","0","0","0","6","518","-1054","530"],["0","0","0","0","0","0","90","-180","90"],["0","0","0","0","0","0","6","-12","6"]]},"deriv_order":1}],"row_multiplier":["0","0","1","-2","1"],"start_base":0,"step_multiplier":{"coeffs":[["0","0","1","-2","1"]]},"step_quotient":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","14","-18","-6","10"],["0","0","9","-7","-13","11"],["0","0","1","1","-5","3"]]},"deriv_order":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","0","0","4","-12","12","-4"],["0","0","0","2","-6","6","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1}]},"shifted_parent_relation":{"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["-10","-10"],["-7","-11"],["-1","-3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","-4","4"],["0","-2","2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"shift":0},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["5"],["6"],["1"]]},"deriv_order":0,"shift":1}]},"statement":"w(n) E = sum_nu H_nu S^nu L' (with any remainder removed by row annihilators of the parent), where L' is the parent rule at P'_n = P_(n+0) (valid from base 0) and E the input rule gauged by lambda(n)/delta(n) and composed with (or conjugated through) T = f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2; so the candidate rows satisfy the input rule at every base n >= 0 (the exceptional bases checked exactly), and agreement on the 1 identifying rows gives Q_n = lambda(n) T_n(P_(n+0)) for every n >= 0"},"method":"operator_division"},"status":"certified"},"input_first_index":0,"interlacing":{"from_index":1,"justification":"the parent theorem (LiuWang) proves P_(m-1) weakly interlacing P_m for every m >= 1; T = f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2 is independent of n and maps every real-rooted polynomial to a real-rooted polynomial or zero, so by the Hermite--Kakeya--Obreschkoff theorem (both directions) T(P_(m-1)) and T(P_m) have weakly interlacing zeros; the nonzero gauge does not move zeros, so Q_(n-1) and Q_n interlace weakly (orientation not determined) for every n >= 1","kind":"weak","orientation":"unordered","status":"claimed"},"lean_declarations":["RealRooted.isMultiplierSequence_eval_of_roots_nonpos","RealRooted.isPFMultiplierSequence_eval_of_roots_nonpos","RealRooted.isMultiplierSequence_iff_preserves"],"lift_summary":{"hypotheses":[{"evidence":"the polynomial with ascending coefficients [1, 2, 1] is fixed; exact check: real-rooted = true, coefficients of one sign = true","name":"euler_polynomial_roots_nonpositive","statement":"the polynomial in theta is real-rooted with every root <= 0 for every n >= n0","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"lambda(n) = 1","name":"gauge_finite_nonzero","statement":"lambda(n) is finite and nonzero for every n >= n0","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"delta(n) != 0 for every integer n in [0, +inf) (exact; Taylor shift: the coefficients of delta(n) at n = 0 + u have one sign)","name":"operator_coefficients_defined","sign_decision":{"certificate":{"condition":"nonzero","denominator":["1"],"method":{"kind":"taylor_shift","shifted_denominator":["1"],"shifted_numerator":["1"]},"numerator":["1"],"range":{"first":"0","last":null}},"decision":"holds"},"statement":"the operator coefficients are finite at every n >= n0 (their denominators do not vanish)","status":{"kind":"verified"}}],"identity":{"method":"forward_division","status":"certified"},"input_first_index":0,"input_interlacing":{"interlacing":{"from_index":1,"justification":{"premises":["the parent theorem (LiuWang) proves P_(m-1) weakly interlacing P_m for every m >= 1; T = f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2 is independent of n and maps every real-rooted polynomial to a real-rooted polynomial or zero, so by the Hermite--Kakeya--Obreschkoff theorem (both directions) T(P_(m-1)) and T(P_m) have weakly interlacing zeros; the nonzero gauge does not move zeros, so Q_(n-1) and Q_n interlace weakly (orientation not determined) for every n >= 1"],"theorem":"Hermite--Kakeya--Obreschkoff theorem (N. Obreschkoff, Verteilung und Berechnung der Nullstellen reeller Polynome, 1963; see S. Fisk, Polynomials, Roots, and Interlacing, arXiv:math/0612833): real polynomials f, g have weakly interlacing zeros iff alpha f + beta g is real-rooted or zero for all real alpha, beta; a linear T independent of n that maps every real-rooted polynomial to a real-rooted polynomial or zero therefore maps interlacing pairs to pairs with weakly interlacing zeros (orientation not determined)"},"kind":"weak","orientation":"unordered"},"status":"proved"},"lean_replay":"not_attempted","operation":{"description":"f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2","kind":"preserver_image","operator":{"coefficients":[{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["2"]},{"denominator":["1"],"numerator":["1"]}],"shape":"euler_polynomial"}},"parent":{"gauge":{"kind":"none"},"index_shift":0,"recurrence":{"first_index":0,"initial_polynomials":[["1"]],"recurrence":{"denominator":{"coeffs":[["0"],["4"],["1"]]},"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["4","2"],["5","5"],["1","3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"offset":1,"sign":"none"},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","2","-2"],["0","2","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"offset":1,"sign":"none"}]},"schema":"polytool.recurrence.v1"},"relation":"Q_n = lambda(n) T_n(P_(n+0)) with T = f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2, for every n >= 0"},"parent_proof":{"route":"liu_wang","statement":"every parent row P_n, n >= 0, is zero or real-rooted with coefficients of one sign","status":"proved"},"root_transfer":{"input_conclusion":"every Q_n, n >= 0, is zero or real-rooted with roots in (-inf, 0]","input_root_region":{"upper":{"closed":true,"value":"0"}},"parent_hypothesis":"every parent row used is zero or real-rooted with all roots in (-inf, 0] (coefficients of one sign)","parent_root_region":{"upper":{"closed":true,"value":"0"}},"theorem":"Laguerre's theorem on multiplier sequences: if f is a real polynomial whose roots are all real and <= 0, then (f(k))_(k >= 0) is a multiplier sequence, so x^k -> f(k) x^k maps every real-rooted polynomial to a real-rooted polynomial or zero (Laguerre; see T. Craven and G. Csordas, Multiplier sequences for fields, Illinois J. Math. 21 (1977); Polya--Schur, Theorem 40 of P. Branden, arXiv:1410.6601: sum_k f(k) x^k / k! = f(theta) e^x = C e^x x^m prod (1 + x/a_j), a_j > 0); f(k) has one sign for k >= 0, so coefficients of one sign stay of one sign; applied to f(n, .) for each n"},"verdict":"proved"},"notes":["the division remainder is removed by row annihilators of the shifted parent"],"parent_interlacing_report":{"conclusion":{"first_index":0,"interlacing":"weak","interlacing_from":1,"root_region":{"upper":{"closed":false,"value":"0"}},"simple_roots":false,"statement":"every P_n, n >= 0, is nonzero and real-rooted with every root in (-inf, 0) (so its coefficients have one sign); deg P_n = deg P_(n-1) + 1 and P_(n-1) interlaces P_n (Liu--Wang) for n >= 1"},"hypotheses":[{"evidence":"f(n) = n^2 + 4 n != 0 for every integer n in [1, +inf) (exact; Taylor shift: the coefficients of f(n) = n^2 + 4 n at n = 1 + u have one sign)","name":"left_factor_nonzero","sign_decision":{"certificate":{"condition":"nonzero","denominator":["1"],"method":{"kind":"taylor_shift","shifted_denominator":["1"],"shifted_numerator":["5","6","1"]},"numerator":["0","4","1"],"range":{"first":"1","last":null}},"decision":"holds"},"statement":"the left-hand factor f(n) is nonzero for every n >= 1","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"P_0 has degree 0; checked exactly","name":"seed_roots_negative","statement":"P_0 is nonzero and real-rooted with every root < 0","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"lambda_n = (n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n) > 0 for every integer n in [1, +inf) (exact; Taylor shift: the coefficients of lambda_n = (n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n) at n = 1 + u have one sign)","name":"degree_step_positive","sign_decision":{"certificate":{"condition":"positive","denominator":["0","4","1"],"method":{"kind":"taylor_shift","shifted_denominator":["5","6","1"],"shifted_numerator":["10","7","1"]},"numerator":["4","5","1"],"range":{"first":"1","last":null}},"decision":"holds"},"statement":"lambda_n = [x^1] a_n + (deg P_(n-1)) [x^2] b_n > 0 for every n >= 1 (deg P_n = deg P_(n-1) + 1 with leading coefficients of one sign)","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"[x^0] c_1(n, x) is the zero polynomial","name":"derivative_coefficient_vanishes_at_zero","statement":"b_n(0) = 0 for every n >= 1","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"b_n(x) = gamma(n) w(x) / f(n) with w(x) = -2 x^2 + 2 x, which is negative on (-inf, 0) (no root there, exact): gamma(n)/f(n) = (n + 1)/(n^2 + 4 n) >= 0 for every integer n in [1, +inf) (exact; Taylor shift: the coefficients of gamma(n)/f(n) = (n + 1)/(n^2 + 4 n) at n = 1 + u have one sign)","name":"derivative_coefficient_nonpositive","sign_decision":{"certificate":{"condition":"nonnegative","denominator":["0","4","1"],"method":{"kind":"taylor_shift","shifted_denominator":["5","6","1"],"shifted_numerator":["2","1"]},"numerator":["1","1"],"range":{"first":"1","last":null}},"decision":"holds"},"statement":"b_n(x) <= 0 for every x < 0 and every n >= 1","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"a_n(0) = (n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n) > 0 for every integer n in [1, +inf) (exact; Taylor shift: the coefficients of a_n(0) = (n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n) at n = 1 + u have one sign)","name":"constant_term_positive","sign_decision":{"certificate":{"condition":"positive","denominator":["0","4","1"],"method":{"kind":"taylor_shift","shifted_denominator":["5","6","1"],"shifted_numerator":["10","7","1"]},"numerator":["4","5","1"],"range":{"first":"1","last":null}},"decision":"holds"},"statement":"a_n(0) > 0 for every n >= 1","status":{"kind":"verified"}},{"evidence":"exact","name":"requested_root_region","statement":"the requested region (-inf, 0) contains (-inf, 0), the region this theorem certifies","status":{"kind":"verified"}}],"lean_replay":"not_attempted","normal_form":"P_n = a_n(x) P_(n-1) + b_n(x) P'_(n-1) for n >= 1, with a_n(x) = ((n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((3 n^2 + 5 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x and b_n(x) = ((0)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((2 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x + ((-2 n - 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x^2","recurrence":{"first_index":0,"initial_polynomials":[["1"]],"recurrence":{"denominator":{"coeffs":[["0"],["4"],["1"]]},"terms":[{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["4","2"],["5","5"],["1","3"]]},"deriv_order":0,"offset":1,"sign":"none"},{"coeff":{"coeffs":[["0","2","-2"],["0","2","-2"]]},"deriv_order":1,"offset":1,"sign":"none"}]},"schema":"polytool.recurrence.v1"},"reference":"L. L. Liu and Y. Wang, A unified approach to polynomial sequences with only real zeros, Adv. in Appl. Math. 38 (2007) 542-560, Theorem 2.1 with g = f' (as in their Corollary 2.4), with nonnegativity of the coefficients replaced by an exact induction keeping every root in (-inf, 0)","requested_root_region":{"upper":{"closed":false,"value":"0"}},"schema":"polytool.recurrence-real-rootedness-theorem.v1","status":"proved","theorem":"liu_wang"},"parent_proof":{"attempts":[{"detail":"the leader is not a nonzero constant","route":"periodic_product","success":false,"variant":"P_(n+k) = c(x) P_n"},{"detail":"no theorem matched (weighted_renewal_window: LHS must be a nonzero constant; fixed_delay_predecessor_window: LHS must be a nonzero constant)","route":"paper_theorem","success":false,"variant":"match_recurrence_theorems"},{"detail":"not applicable: the theorem needs at least two seed rows","route":"three_term_recurrence","success":false,"variant":"three_term_recurrence"},{"detail":"P_n = a_n(x) P_(n-1) + b_n(x) P'_(n-1) for n >= 1, with a_n(x) = ((n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((3 n^2 + 5 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x and b_n(x) = ((0)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((2 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x + ((-2 n - 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x^2: every P_n, n >= 0, is nonzero and real-rooted with every root in (-inf, 0) (so its coefficients have one sign); deg P_n = deg P_(n-1) + 1 and P_(n-1) interlaces P_n (Liu--Wang) for n >= 1","route":"liu_wang","success":true,"variant":"liu_wang"}],"conditional_on":[],"interlacing":{"from_index":1,"justification":{"premises":["every hypothesis of the theorem is verified exactly for every index: P_n = a_n(x) P_(n-1) + b_n(x) P'_(n-1) for n >= 1, with a_n(x) = ((n^2 + 5 n + 4)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((3 n^2 + 5 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x and b_n(x) = ((0)/(n^2 + 4 n)) + ((2 n + 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x + ((-2 n - 2)/(n^2 + 4 n)) x^2","every P_n, n >= 0, is nonzero and real-rooted with every root in (-inf, 0) (so its coefficients have one sign); deg P_n = deg P_(n-1) + 1 and P_(n-1) interlaces P_n (Liu--Wang) for n >= 1"],"theorem":"liu_wang: L. L. Liu and Y. Wang, A unified approach to polynomial sequences with only real zeros, Adv. in Appl. Math. 38 (2007) 542-560, Theorem 2.1 with g = f' (as in their Corollary 2.4), with nonnegativity of the coefficients replaced by an exact induction keeping every root in (-inf, 0)"},"kind":"weak","orientation":"previous_interlaces_next"},"route":"liu_wang","rows_checked":10,"statement":"every parent row P_n, n >= 0, is zero or real-rooted with coefficients of one sign","status":"proved"},"rows_compared":16,"schema":"polytool.recurrence-preserver-image.v1","statement":"proved: Q_n = lambda(n) T_n(P_(n+0)) with T = f(n, theta) = 1 + (2) theta + (1) theta^2 for every n >= 0, the side conditions hold for every n, and every parent row P_n, n >= 0, is zero or real-rooted with coefficients of one sign; so every Q_n, n >= 0, is zero or real-rooted with roots in (-inf, 0]"},"kind":"preserver_image"}